Breaking Dawn, Friendship is Magic

diciembre 4, 2012 at 8:51 pm (Animation, Film, Stuff) (, , , )

Thanks to a variety of circumstances, I had managed to avoid directly consuming the twin phenomenons that are the Twilight series and My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic for the majority of their lifespans.  Twilight never interested me except as something to dissect, and although I was interested in My Little Pony based on good word of mouth, I believed that it wasn’t available by legal means in my neck of the woods.

Last week though, circumstances changed when it came to both: dad rented Breaking Dawn Part. 1, giving me both the opportunity to watch it without having to spend three to six dollars and an impetus to watch the final movie in theaters.  Better yet, I realized that another channel besides the unavailable The Hub carried Friendship is Magic, meaning I could watch two episodes per day if I so chose. So, throughout the week, I caught six random episodes of ponies, and watched vampires decapitate one another on Saturday.

It’s weird.  Twilight, when taken as a whole, is an incredibly problematic work.  As a work of cinema, breaking dawn has little to recommend it when it comes to pacing, character development, tone, plot, originality, camera work, visuals, etcetera, etcetera.  Meanwhile, My Little Pony was created/developed by the woman behind the excellent Super-Best Friends Forever shorts on DC Nation, has a devious sense of humor, likeable characters, a nice aesthetic, and, according to others, a certain something that makes it appealing to groups outside of its original intended demographic.  And yet, after watching them both, I can say without reservation which one captivated me more, and it’s not the that most people in my circle would consider  good.

I’ve mentioned that I tend to appreciate interesting concepts coupled with flawed execution more than I like the opposite.  Generator Rex may have squandered every opportunity it had to be awesome, but in the end, it was a show about a world in which every organism in the world had been infected by a virus that could randomly mutate them into random monsters at random moments, which meant that I was willing to forgive a whole lot of bullshit if it meant not missing the moment when all that promise was realized (it never did).

The power of that sort of premise, to me, is it’s ability to suggest.  Now matter how comprehensive the show is, there will always be tons of stuff they won’t be able to cover, which allows my imagination to step in and fill in the gaps.

As relates to Twilight, my lack of familiarity with most of the story helps immeasurably.  Breaking Dawn is a story about characters with a history; they have had specific interactions that have led them to become the people on the screen.  Given the series, the canonical version of that history probably isn’t all that all that interesting, but in any case, my ignorance of it allows me to set it aside in favor of whatever I put my mind to.  I can think of Alice and Bella as besties, or that Bella and Edwards’s relationship is actually based on mutual respect for one another.  As far as I know, the Volturi, the awesomely campy cabal of vampire baddies in hoods that form the locus of conflict in the second movie have done nothing to make me doubt their competence.  It makes it much easier to root for the characters, who are generally played by actors, who if nothing else, are very pretty and don’t take me out of the action–that’s the director’s job.

Sure, the first part, dealing mostly with Bella’s wedding, honeymoon is rather boring .  But it’s an interesting kind of boring.  It’s boring I’d never seen attempted before and features Ashley Greene as Alice and a cameo by Anna Kendrick, whom I’ll always have time for (I can’t believe I missed Pitch Perfect).  The second part, on the other hand, deals with vampires all over the world (a lot of them with superpowers that come in addition to the standard vampire deal) choosing sides for the conflict that may ensue due to Bella and Edward’s half-vampire kid.  It features the good guy vampires reuniting form a war council, which is a trope I have excessive amounts of love for, and actors like scruffy Lee Pace (love) and Rami Malek, who steals every scene he’s in as Benjamin, a vampire who is basically also the Avatar.  Basically, there’s pretty people and oddball accents galore, culminating in a battle scene that ends in a way I think is both a cop-out and brilliant.    By the end, when the credits start rolling in a really retrospective-y way that highlights, again, the history the actors have with each other, I was getting a little misty, not because I cared about Bella or Edward, but because I was saying goodbye to a ‘verse, that, with a little love and tender care, could have been something special.  I may never get to see that spin-off movie where Alice and Benjamin travel across the world being awesome, but a guy can dream, can’t he?

Ironically, Friendship is Magic, which I feel is supposed to be about the power of imagination, doesn’t manage to press those buttons.  Although the world-building is solid and surprisingly well thought out, and I have little doubt, way more coherent than Twilight’s, the episodes themselves feel too pat to elicit curiosity.  Coupled with (as far as I’ve seen) rather predictable plotting, it does little to elicit my attention.  It’s not a bad work, but its one that is clearly not aimed at me, and that’s fine.



4 comentarios

  1. Pterobat said,

    I admit to being one of those people who has never read or seen much of Twilight, and dislikes it based on what I’ve heard. The last filim sounded like a lot of punch-pulling and wish fulfillment for Bella, who had been begging to become a vampire all this time and now gets it, and loves it, with no other consequences. Even the fight scene turned out to be just a dream sequence, which you can only get away with if you’re Phoenix Ikki from Saint Seiya.

    “Friendship is Magic” is interesting because I tried to like it, and I sort of did, but never achieved the heights of addiction that a lot of people did. It always seemed to me that the series didn’t give me much that I could not get from other cartoons, with the exception of a good and well-rounded female cast (Twilight Sparkle was my favourite). I haven’t even kept up with the third season, though that might be due to a toxic mix of low interest levels and finding out about the show’s creepy fandom.

    I still ended up buying enough Twilight Sparkle figures to open my own corral though. 😛 Maybe I tried hard to like the series because it appealed to a nostalgia for a girly childhood that I had never had.

  2. Pterobat said,

    Oh, and have you been keeping up with my Ninja Turtltes posts? I just finished season 3 and will be writing a review shortly.

  3. Ian said,

    Hey! : )

    Yes, I’ve been keeping up, and I plan on commenting on them–and your Griffith post–as soon as possible, hopefully before the end of the week.

    What, having to live with Edward isn’t negative enough? 😛 Yes, the vampires in Meyer’s series could use a weakness or ten–or at least more emphasis on the few drawbacks that do exist, such as the loss of a sense of taste (which really, when compared with what one gains…it’s not a deal I’d have trouble making, I think). That said, I did enjoy seeing Bella enjoy being powerful and getting her wishes fulfilled,in a subjective, non-critical sort of way. It always seems that power, like immortality, is one of those things one isn’t allowed to wish for even though they’re morally neutral, so seeing someone get them because they wanted them, with no strings attached satisfied me. Even if it doesn’t make for the most interesting of stories.

    I also rather liked that it was all a future vision, since it allowed the bad guy vampires to seem smarter than they would have seemed if they’d actually gone through with it. Plus, I thought it was a semi-elegant solution to the screenwriter’s dilemma of having to adapt what was, I believe, an unreasonably short segment of the final book–and one that feels entirely out of place when tacked onto Bella’s pregnancy travails, which comprise the bulk of the source material–into an actual movie.

    Yes, I think that’s exactly what I find unsatisfying about Friendship is Magic: eliminate the cast–which I realize is no small thing, and a huge part of what makes the show important and worth emulating–and it doesn’t scratch any itches that something like Adventure Time doesn’t scratch better. I keep wanting it to be wilder, smarter, more challenging…and then I remember that it does a spectacular job of hitting the target it’s actually aiming for, and that given that I already have Adventure Time, it feels greedy to expect this, too, to cater to my whims.

  4. Pterobat said,


    Well, I come from the school of thought that the more conflict and surprises you throw at the characters, the better the story comes out. “Character wants something and then gets it, and it’s as good as they hoped”, just doesn’t sound compelling to me.

    It’s the same reason why I generally don’t like vampires being portrayed as superheroes: how are they “monsters” if they get what they want?

    I think the best genre stories function on a microcosmic and macrocosmic level, where there is both compelling character drama and a “fate of the world” stuff. Pruning potential macrocosmic conflict whenever it arises sounds like Twilight’s stock-in-trade, and the battle scene turning out to be a vision sounds like the last of it. It’s the same lack of consequences issue that comes with Bella’s wish-fulfillment.

    God (Glob?) I love “Adventure Time” to bits, much more than FiM, for all the reasons you state. I don’t think asking MLP to thread off the beaten path is asking for it to “cater” to you, since “Aventure Time” is apparently successful with kids despite all its weirdness. Trust me, wishing for MLP to take more chances has nothing to do with the creepy demands the fandom places upon it. And in fact, after so many people raved about MLP, the expectation that it was something grand and exciting was also generated. When that doesn’t pan out, it’s only natural to imagine what exactly it was lacking.


Introduce tus datos o haz clic en un icono para iniciar sesión:

Logo de

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Imagen de Twitter

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Twitter. Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Foto de Facebook

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Facebook. Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Google+ photo

Estás comentando usando tu cuenta de Google+. Cerrar sesión / Cambiar )

Conectando a %s

A %d blogueros les gusta esto: